BazEkon - The Main Library of the Cracow University of Economics

BazEkon home page

Main menu

Author
Ziemblicki Bartosz (Wroclaw University)
Title
Some Thoughts on the Axiology and Constitutionalization of the World Trade Organization
Source
Wroclaw Review of Law, Administration & Economics, 2011, vol. 1, nr 1, s. 51-66, tab.
Keyword
Handel międzynarodowy, Prawo międzynarodowe, Wzrost gospodarczy, Sprawiedliwy handel, Przewaga komparatywna
International trade, International law, Economic growth, Fair trade, Comparative advantage
Note
summ.
Company
Światowa Organizacja Handlu
World Trade Organization (WTO)
Abstract
The rationale for the existence of the WTO is the assumption that international trade is beneficial to all parties. The theoretical justification for this assumption is the theory of comparative advantage. The WTO may also be credited with a contribution to peacekeeping and has strong doctrinal and philosophical foundations. The WTO is often accused of a bias towards exporters and failure to provide appropriate protection to other market participants. Other conflicting powers within the Organization are the supporters of free trade and fair trades. The third doctrinal tension is between the legislative and judicial powers. The Ministerial Conferences are ever more unable to make decisions and reform the WTO. At the same time a very effective dispute settlement mechanism is beginning to fill the gaps in legal texts. The WTO is often presented as an example of the ongoing process of constitutionalization of international law. The concept is difficult to define and each scholar distinguishes different characteristics. It is arguable whether the WTO is undergoing the process of constitutionalization and also whether it can be perceived as a self-contained régime. The contribution of the WTO to global governance in comparison to that of the GATT is another issue under discussion. (original abstract)
Full text
Show
Bibliography
Show
  1. Signed in Marrakesh, Morocco, on April 15, 1994, at the conclusion of the Uruguay Round of Multilateral Trade Negotiations.
  2. Signed in Geneva, Switzerland, on October 30, 1947.
  3. JH Jackson, World Trade and the Law of GATT (Indianapolis 1969) 38.
  4. RD Anderson, H Wager, Human Rights, Development, and the WTO: the Cases of Intellectual Property and Competition Policy (2006) 9(3) "Journal of International Economic Law" 707, 713-714.
  5. Arthur Herman, How the Scots Invented the Modern World (New York 2002).
  6. A Treatise of Human Nature (1739).
  7. Historical Law Tracts (1758).
  8. Essay on the Nature and Conduct of the Passions and Affections, with Illustrations of the Moral Sense (1928).
  9. Garry Wills, Inventing America: Jefferson's Declaration of Independence (New York2002) 248-55.
  10. To Perpetual Peace: A Philosophical Sketch (1795).
  11. Jerzy Chodorowski, Adam Smith (Wrocław 1980) 40.
  12. H. Olszewski, M. Zmierczak, Historia Doktryn Politycznych i Prawnych (Poznań 1994)166.
  13. Wacław Stankiewicz, Historia myśli ekonomicznej (Warszawa 1983) 170.
  14. E-U Petersmann, Challenges to the Legitimacy and Efficiency of the World Trading System: Democratic Governance and Competition Culture in the WTO. Introduction and Summary(2004) 7(3) "Journal of International Economic Law" 585, 587.
  15. The Prince (1513).
  16. E-U Petersmann, The WTO Constitution and Human Rights (2000) 3(1) "Journal of International Economic Law" 19, 24.
  17. An Essay on the External Corn Trade (1780).
  18. T. Rynarzewski, A. Zielińska - Głebocka, Międzynarodowe stosunki gospodarcze (Warszawa 2006) 59.
  19. Adam Budnikowski, Międzynarodowe stosunki gospodarcze (Warszawa 2003) 42.
  20. Urszula Zagóra - Jonszta, Wykłady z historii myśli ekonomicznej (Katowice 1998) 71.
  21. GDA MacDougall, British and American Exports: A Study Suggested by the Theory of Comparative Cost (1951) 61 "Economic Journal" 697.
  22. RM Stern, British and American Productivity and Comparative Costs in International Trade(1962) 14 "Oxford Economic Papers" 275.
  23. Bela Balassa, An Empirical Determination of Classical Comparative Cost Theory (1963) 45(3) "Review of Economics and Statistics" 231.
  24. Thomas Cottier, Trade and Human Rights: A Relationship to Discover (2002) 5(1) "Journal of International Economic Law" 111, 115.
  25. JH Jackson, The WTO Constitution and Proposed Reforms: Seven Mantras Revisited(2001) 4(1) "Journal of International Economic Law" 67, 68.
  26. Gudrun Zagel, The WTO and Trade-related Human Rights Measures: Trade Sanctions vs. Trade Incentives http://www.ipfw.edu/hri/WTO/Zagel - ARIEL.pdf accessed 10 March 2011, 7.
  27. Singapore Ministerial Declaration adopted on 13 December 1996, WTO document WT/MIN(96)/DEC, par. 4.
  28. Annex 1B to the WTO Agreement.
  29. Annex 1A to the WTO Agreement.
  30. Annex 1C to the WTO Agreement.
  31. E-U Petersmann, European and International Constitutional Law: Time for Promoting Cosmopolitan Democracy in the WTO in G de Burca, J Scott (eds), The EU and the WTO.Legal and Constitutional Issues (Oxford - Portland Oregon 2003) 101.
  32. E-U Petersmann, Constitutionalism and International Organizations (1996) 17 "Northwestern Journal of International Law and Business" 398, 415.
  33. Steve Charnovitz, World Trade Organization in 2020 (2004-2005) 1(1-2) "Journal of International Law & International Relations" 167, 177.
  34. Mattoo, A Subramanian, The WTO and the Poorest Countries: the Stark Reality(2004) "World Trade Review" 3, 385, 393.
  35. MP Maduro, Is there such thing as free or fair trade? in G de Burca, J Scott (eds)The EU and the WTO.Legal and Constitutional Issues (Oxford - Portland Oregon 2003)258.
  36. Kal Raustiala, Compliance and Effectiveness in International Regulatory Cooperation(2000) 32 "Case Western Reserve Journal of International Law" 387, 438.
  37. CM Vazques, Trade Sanctions and Human Rights - Past, Present and Future (2003) 6(4) "Journal of International Economic Law" 797, 803.
  38. GC Shaffer, Defending Interests: Public-Private Partnerships in WTO Litigation (Washington 2003) 2-3.
  39. J Cameron, KR Gray, Principles of International Law inthe WTO Dispute Settlement Body (2001) "International and Comparative Law Quarterly" 50, 248, 250.
  40. RCh Wolf, Trade, Aid, andArbitrate: The Globalization of Western Law (Aldershot 2004) 196.
  41. DP Steger, The Future of the WTO: The Case for Institutional Reform (2009) 12(4) "Journal of International Economic Law" 803, 809-810.
  42. RH Steinberg, Judicial Lawmaking at the WTO: Discursive, Constitutional, and Political Constraints (2004) 98 "American Journal of International Law" 247, 274.
  43. Article VI:2 b GATS, Article 42 and 46 TRIPS,Article 16:3 SCM, Article 4.2 Anti-dumping.
  44. Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, Article 27.
  45. RMM Wallace, International Law (London 2002) 35.
  46. J Klabbers, A Peters, G Ulfstein (eds), The Constitutionalization of International Law(Oxford 2009) 6-7.
  47. Neil Walker, The EU and the WTO: Constitutionalism in a New Key in G de Burca, J Scott (eds) The EU and the WTO.Legal and Constitutional Issues (Oxford - Portland Oregon 2003) 31.
  48. JP Trachtman, The Constitutions of the WTO , (2006) 17(3) "European Journal of International Law" 623.
  49. Cezary Mik, Prawo Światowej Organizacji Handlu (WTO) a prawo Wspólnot Europejskich, in J Kolasa, A Kozłowski (eds) Prawo międzynarodowe publiczne a prawo europejskie (Wrocław 2003) 80.
  50. Peter Holmes, The WTO and the EU: Some Constitutional Comparisonsin G de Burca, J Scott (eds) The EU and the WTO.Legal and Constitutional Issues (Oxford - Portland Oregon 2003) 63.
  51. JL Dunoff, Constitutional Conceits: the WTO's Constitution and the Discipline of International Law (2006) 17(3) "European Journal of International Law" 647, 647-676.
  52. JH Jackson, World Trade and the Law of GATT (Indianapolis 1968) 788.
  53. AO Sykes, International Trade and Human Rights - an Economic Perspective in FM Abbott, Ch Breining-Kaufmann, T Cottier (eds), International Trade and Human Rights: Foundation and Conceptual Issues (2005) 5 World Trade Forum, University of Michigan Press chapter 4.
  54. P Krugman, M Obstfeld, International Economics: Theory and Practice (Addison Wesley 2005).
  55. Article V:1 of the WTO Agreement.
  56. Article 1:3 TRIPS.
  57. Eg the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea in panel report WT/DS58/R.
  58. D Palmeter, P Mavroidis, The WTO Legal System: Sources of Law (1998) 92(3) "American Journal of International Law" 398, 413.
  59. G Marceau, WTO Dispute Settlement and Human Rights(2002) 13 "European Journal of International Law" 753, 755.
  60. Konrad Czernichowski, Współpraca z innymi organizacjami międzynarodowymi: cele i formy współpracy - studium przypadku, in J Rymarczyk, M Wróblewski (eds), 10 lat WTO (Wrocław 2005) 192-193.
  61. JN Rosenau, EO Czempiel (eds), Governance without Government. Order and Change in World Politics (Cambridge 1992).
  62. JN Rosenau, Toward an Ontology for global Governance in M Hewson, TJ Sinclair, Approaches to GlobalGovernance (New York 1999).
  63. VK Aggarwal, Reconciling Institutions: Nested, Horizontal, Overlapping, and Independent Institutions, http://www.princeton.edu/~smeunier/Aggarwal memo.pdfaccessed 01.03.2011.
  64. Małgorzata Grącik, Światowa Organizacja Handlu jako przykład otwartej koordynacji międzynarodowego systemu handlowego in Katarzyna Żukrowska (ed), Otwarta koordynacji stosunkach międzynarodowych (Warszawa 2007) 20.
  65. RO Keohane, JS Ney, The club model of multilateral cooperation and problems of democratic legitimacy in RO Keohane, JS Ney (eds), Power and Governance in a Partially Globalized World (Routledge, London 2002).
  66. Pascal Lamy, Europe and the Future of Economic Governance (2004) 42 (1) "Journal of Market Studies" 9.
Cited by
Show
ISSN
2084-1264
Language
eng
Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Google+ Share on Pinterest Share on LinkedIn Wyślij znajomemu